10th June 2009
Disillusion or Dissolution?
Today Parliament will discuss Plaid and the SNP’s motion in favour of the dissolution of Parliament which would trigger a General Election. This is the first time ever that Parliament has discussed a motion on its own dissolution. Traditionally, Opposition parties would put down votes of confidence and if the Government lost, they would then head over to Buckingham palace and seek a dissolution.
This happened in 1979 – on a Tory No Confidence motion, not an SNP motion as Labour often wrongly asserts. The Plaid MPs back then – Dafydd Elis Thomas, Dafydd Wigley and Gwynfor Evans – all backed the Government: the Government in return agreed to push through the legislation on Welsh slate quarrymen’s compensation as part of the ‘wash-up’ – the last-minute legislation that precedes a dissolution.
You have to go back to 1924 and Ramsay MacDonald’s (also a Welsh MP, like Jim Callaghan in 1979) Labour Government that lost a censure vote and opted for dissolution – deliberately in order to decimate the Liberals and help create the two-party system that lasted for the best part of fifty years.
Today, it’s Labour’s future that hangs in the balance. It seems likely that most Labour MPs will opt for the long drawn-out pain of a slow death rather than the sudden catharsis of an immediate election. Brown will announce the Iraq war inquiry that fittingly was the subject of our last parliamentary debate back in October 2006. Then the Government’s position was there was no need: now Brown will hail it as evidence of yet another fresh start.
Even if we lose tonight, the chances are that the governing party will eventually come around to our way of thinking a second time. Despite the show of unity, the chances of an early dissolution of Parliament are still evens – with a new leader installed in the Autumn and an election in early Spring. But the prospect of the Labour Party being submerged under a deluge of public opprobrium with Brown like Captain Ahab determined to go down with the ship (or was it the whale) is also equally possible.
We deliberately chose not to personalise the issue, though the precedent is there: on July 4th 1977, (independence day) Plaid and the SNP put down a motion halving the Prime Minister’s salary – a traditional means of censuring a minister. It lost by just 29 votes. I wonder how close it’ll be tonight, and if the Prime Minister will scurry away after his statement to the House.
Whatever the programme for constitutional or parliamentary reform the Government unveils today the truth is that they lack the moral authority to implement it. It would be luck building a house on the sands: whatever he does or says, the tide of public opinion will soon wash this Prime Minister and his much-vaunted legacy away.
3 Responses to “Disillusion or Dissolution?”
Leave a Reply
You can comment on this article. but you must register first.
Your reply will be moderated and not appear immediately.
You can prepare your text in a word processor before pasting it into the box, but formatting such as bold and colour will not appear.
You must be logged in to post a comment.
marcscaife says:
June 17th, 2009 at 1:12 am
Again Adam, you seem to relish the prospect of a Tory government - can you tell us what exactly is your agenda on this?
Marc
Adam says:
June 18th, 2009 at 11:23 am
Marc,
Anyone who knows me and my politics would know that your charge that I am somehow a closet Tory is patently absurd. I am not a tribal politician and I will work with Conservative MPs where we share common ground - next week’s vote on a proper public inquiry into the Iraq war is a good example.
However, I am a socialist by conviction. For me the question of social justice is intrinsic to my politics. Unlike some on the Labour benches at Westminster I have not jettisoned my political beliefs when they were no longer convenient.
I do not want to see right-wing economic policies, illegal wars, infringements of civil liberties, privatisation or cuts in public expenditure from any London Government - but that’s what we’ver had under a Labour Government that turned its back on its principles. If ordinary people now think there’s little difference between voting Labour or voting Conservative, then quite frankly you (or rather the Labour leadership) only have yourselves to blame. Our dissolution motion reflected our and the public’s deep dissatisfaction with the politics of New Labour.
Progressives in Wales now need to have a different discussion about how we can create a political alternative out of the ashes of this failed Labour government. If you are prepared to have that debate, Marc, then great. That’s what I was trying to do at the Compass conference last weekend.
marcscaife says:
June 25th, 2009 at 10:56 am
Adam, I would not insult you by insinuating that you are a closet Tory, I fully appreciate that you are a socialist and I respect you for that.
My question was however whether you have a hidden agenda to bring in a Tory government: There is now a vast difference between us (Labour) and the Tories, our handling of the economic crisis is supporting vulnerable people through these difficult times (no need to go into detail here, but I will if you like), and the Tories will reverse all our efforts, and you know it! This will bring immediate severe economic hardship to Wales; why are you calling for dissolution - what is your agenda?
Marc